EG Fire Chief Says Warwick Dropped Ball On Dispatch
Chief Henrikson says Warwick should have just come out and said they weren't interested instead of stringing the EGFD on.
The Warwick Fire Department was “weeks” away from taking over EG fire dispatch when the whole plan came to a halt, said Fire Chief Peter Henrikson in an interview Tuesday.
Henrikson had a pile of papers to document what took since 2009 to transfer East Greenwich fire dispatch duties to Warwick because the EGFD has come under fire lately for spending $147,000 on equipment for both EG and Warwick that is now not needed.
East Greenwich Fire Commissioners voted to end dispatch consolidation talks with Warwick at their meeting on Jan. 24.
Henrikson said the impetus for moving dispatch to Warwick was to free up a firefighter from doing dispatch. Paid firefighters covering dispatch dates back to the1980s. A internal study from 1990 recommended moving a non-firefighter (who would be paid less) into that position.
That idea was never acted on during contract negotiations.
The idea to move EGFD dispatch to Warwick came from former EGFD Commissioner Christine Mattos. Then-EG Fire Chief John McKenna met with then-Warwick Fire Chief Kevin Sullivan and Mayor Scott Avedisian in March 2009. A letter from Warwick city attorney Diana Pearson after that meeting states:
“As discussed and agreed, it would make a great deal of financial sense to shift your fire dispatch needs to our facilities and staff.”
A memo from Chief McKenna to the EG Fire Commissioners dated Jan. 25, 2010, outlines the expenditures needed to make the move: $42,000 for EGFD and $28,000 for WFD. This does not include two microwave dishes (one for each town) that were added as an extra layer of backup.
A letter from Feb. 1, 2010, from McKenna to Sullivan reads: “The City of Warwick and the East Greenwich Fire District have come to a mutual agreement to expedite the completion of joint dispatch.”
During 2010, equipment was purchased and installed in fire facilities in both Warwick and East Greenwich. But renovations at the Warwick Fire Dispatch Center on Sandy Lane slowed activity. A letter Feb. 23, 2011, from Sullivan to then-EGFD Commission Chair Doug Axelsen laid out a timeline for final equipment installation and adjustments that suggested Warwick would be ready to take over dispatch by June 2011.
That letter also asks Axelsen for a letter “telling us the status of the talks between the East Greenwich Fire District and the Town of East Greenwich with regard to the fire department being moved under the direction of the Town Manager.... We are concerned as to what is the status of those discussions.”
At that point, the Town of East Greenwich was not in merger talks with the Fire District, but a year later the Town Council put a question on the ballot asking if the Fire District should merge with the town. Those plans are now moving forward.
Sullivan retired July 30, 2011. According to Henrikson, everything froze after that. The new Warwick fire chief, Edmund Armstrong, could not be reached for this article. According to Mayor Avedisian earlier this month, Armstrong wanted to review the entire department before deciding whether or not to take on EG dispatch duties.
Meanwhile, the EGFD and the firefighters union worked out an agreement last summer so that working dispatch would be considered “collateral duty,” no longer part of the firefighters' assigned duty. Firefighters would cover dispatch in their off time and be paid at a dispatch rate rather than the higher firefighter pay. That freed up the district to add a firefighter to help cover Station 2, a longtime goal.
For Henrikson, the frustration has been Warwick’s lack of response. “Four years. How much longer do we have to wait?” he said Tuesday. “To this day, they haven’t told us why.”
He said they'd retrieved some equipment from Warwick already, about $12,000 to $15,000 worth. One decoder was being used by Warwick; Henrikson said he would bill Warwick for that. The big-ticket item is the microwave system, which cost $54,000. The vendor needs to remove those dishes. Henrikson said he's looking into re-selling them.
T
7:02 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013
Kudos to Mayor Avedisian and his staff for not falling for this. This was a terrible deal for the city of Warwick that needs no explanation, however, since it continually seems to come up here, here goes. The city of Warwick pays the town of East Greenwich a little over $300,000 to cover the Potowamut section of the city of Warwick. East greenwich wanted to take $100,000 off that (Potowamut) bill in return for Warwick's taking over dispatch. East Greenwich would be able to take the firefighter off the "desk" that dispatches and place him on the rescue, placing another truck in service effectively transferring almost all liability to the City. There are streets with the same name, trucks with the same name etc. What seemed good in theory (as far as E.G.was concerned) doesn't translate well into real life. Warwick is building a fire station in Potowamut and saving themselves over $300,000 and that's why this never got off the ground and the chief in E.G. knew this. So yes, I agree that this was a good deal for them, and I can see why they would be excited for this, however, not so good for my city though.
EG Lurker
11:45 am on Friday, February 15, 2013
Kudos? Maybe I'm misreading this article and the linked back-articles, but Avedisian seems to be apologetic, disappointed regarding the lack of progress - until the new Warwick chief came along, it appears Warwick was on board...
Leo
7:55 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013
Does anyone know when and where a fire station is going to be built in Potowomut? I know this was voted in years ago but I have heard nothing about it.
Elizabeth McNamara
8:04 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013
There are no firm plans, this is from Mayor Avedisian's email to me on Feb. 4:
"Warwick currently pays East Greenwich $320,000 a year for fire and rescue in the Potowomut and Bay Ridge areas of the city of Warwick. We were talking about $100,000 for dispatch. At the same time, the Warwick School Department turned over the old Potowomut School to the city. Chief Armstrong would like to analyze whether or not he could use that land for fire service so that way we could end the annual $320,000 payment to East Greenwich."
T
8:16 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013
Elizabeth, if you were the mayor of Warwick would you have done this?
Elizabeth McNamara
8:28 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013
T, luckily for Warwick, I'm not! I'm a reporter.
T
8:47 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013
I'll take that as a no. I don't think you can lay blame at the Mayor or the Chief here they're doing their jobs. The bottom line is there was never a deal, only preliminary talks. Chief Henrickson took it upon himself to make these purchases to wit he will have to answer for. Can we all move on now?
Mutato
12:35 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013
You would think you'd be waiting until a deal was completed in writing before commiting to buying a lot of expensive equipment. Poor management decision.
FriendOfEG
10:10 pm on Saturday, February 16, 2013
Ummm....Jillian...EG hasn't had volunteer firefighter in almost 10 years.
Jillian Preble
5:58 pm on Sunday, February 17, 2013
Whoops-that's what I get for posting exhusted :) I was thinking of other places that do, sorry, my mistake. I find it so funny that Potowomut means land of fire with all of the what to do with a fire station.
Jillian Preble
12:12 am on Monday, February 18, 2013
Where in Potowomut is there space? Ives is all owned land. Not sure the deed from Gaddard would allow one in the park. The deed doesn't even allow overhead telephone wires. Knock down the old school and build there is the only place I may see.